Imagine if you had made that same comment in a case of the same discrimination against another skin color that wasn't white. Heads would roll.

So much for "having empathy for someone outside my identity group".

Given that many such comments also amount to gaslighting, that's what bothers people about the whole idea. It was a good experiment, but it's time to end the policies and the attitude it brings. There are better things to argue over, this isn't one of them.